Pin it
These soft, crumbly treats go by different names worldwide, but everyone agrees their buttery goodness and powdered sugar dusting make them impossible to resist. In our family, Grandma always called them Sugar Butter Balls, and they've been part of our holiday get-togethers for as long as I can remember.
I brought these to a cookie swap last Christmas and before the party ended, three guests had already cornered me for the instructions! There's something about that mix of buttery cookie base and sweet sugar coating that folks just can't say no to.
Key Ingredients and Shopping Advice
- Butter - Grab unsalted butter and let it soften for easier mixing
- Powdered Sugar - Gives the dough its soft texture and creates that smooth, non-gritty coating
- Vanilla Extract - Go for real instead of artificial for tastier results
- All-Purpose Flour - The foundation of our simple dough
- Nuts - Tiny chopped bits of pecans or walnuts add wonderful crunch and flavor
The real trick happens when you roll the warm cookies in powdered sugar, creating that sweet outer layer that dissolves right when you take a bite.
Step-by-Step Baking Guide
- Step 1: Mix Your Dough
- Beat the softened butter with powdered sugar and vanilla until it looks pale and fluffy. Slowly mix in flour and salt, stopping once it's just combined so the dough stays tender. Carefully fold in the finely chopped nuts until they're spread throughout.
- Step 2: Form Your Cookies
- Take small spoonfuls of dough and roll them between your hands into 1-inch balls. Put them on a baking sheet lined with parchment, keeping about an inch between each since they won't grow much while baking.
- Step 3: Bake Carefully
- Pop them in a 400°F oven for 10-12 minutes until they're firm but not brown. You'll know they're done when they feel set to touch but still look white. Don't leave them in too long or they'll turn out dry.
- Step 4: First Sugar Coating
- Let the cookies sit for just a minute on the baking sheet, then carefully roll each hot cookie in powdered sugar. The heat helps this first layer stick and partly melt into the cookie.
- Step 5: Let Them Rest
- Put your sugar-covered cookies on a rack and wait until they're totally cool. This waiting part matters before you add more sugar.
- Step 6: Final Sugar Layer
- Once totally cool, roll each cookie in powdered sugar again for that pretty snow-white look. This second coat sticks better to cool cookies and gives you that perfect sweet outside.
Pin it
The Rich History Behind Traditional Treats
These special cookies hold meaning in many cultures. Some call them Russian Tea Cakes while in Mexico they're known as Polvorones. They often show up at weddings and special events as symbols of happiness and purity. The white sugar coating stands for fresh starts, which is why they fit so well at holiday parties when we think about the past year and dream about what's next.
Great Ideas for Giving
Almost everyone loves getting these cookies as a gift. I pack them in pretty tins with colorful tissue paper for holiday presents that feel special and made with love. They don't break easily during travel and stay tasty for several days, so they work well for mailing to family far away or bringing to parties.
Pin it
Sweet Memories From Long Ago
I still remember watching my grandma's hands—so gentle but quick—rolling each ball just right. I'd stand close by, waiting for her to smile and sneak me a warm cookie. That amazing feeling of the cookie melting away followed by that little cloud of sugar that always made us giggle is still one of my favorite childhood memories.
Family Twists on a Classic
Though I treasure my grandma's version above all, I've tried tons of different takes from friends and relatives. Some folks add a touch of cinnamon or almond flavor, others mix in lemon zest for brightness. In Mexico, many bakers put in anise seed for a hint of licorice taste. Every family changes the basic idea to make it their own special version that gets handed down to kids and grandkids.
Important Reminders
- Handle the dough gently or you'll end up with hard cookies
- Take them out while still pale, never let them brown
- Do the first sugar coating while they're still hot
- Wait till they're completely cool for the second coating
- Keep in a sealed container so they stay fresh
When I first tried making these at 18, I thought I'd be clever and shake them in a bag with sugar instead of rolling each one. Big mistake! Half of them broke apart! I learned that Grandma's careful method of handling each cookie really does work best.
Insider Baking Secrets
- Cut the nuts into tiny pieces for better texture
- Spoon flour into your measuring cups instead of digging in
- Make sure your butter isn't cold when you start mixing
- Cool cookies just briefly before the first sugar roll - about 1-2 minutes
- Try adding a tiny bit of food coloring to the sugar for fancy occasions
Pin it
These Mexican Wedding Cookies have become what everyone expects from me during the holidays. Each year, my friends and family look forward to seeing them on my cookie plates or getting them as presents. The steps are so basic that I can make them with my kids now, keeping the tradition going just like Grandma did with me.
Last-Minute Advice
- Always make extra - they won't last long!
- Keep them in a sealed container at room temp for up to a week
- You can freeze the cookies without sugar coating for 3 months
- When giving as gifts, put wax paper between layers so they don't stick
- They taste amazing with hot tea or coffee to balance the sweetness
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What kind of nuts should I use?
- Pecans are the usual pick, but walnuts are just as tasty.
- → Why coat them twice in powdered sugar?
- Dusting warm cookies sticks sugar on them; the second layer after cooling makes them perfect.
- → Can these cookies stay frozen?
- Sure thing, freeze for up to three months before dusting the final sugar coat.
- → Why're they named wedding cookies?
- They're a popular celebration snack at weddings and parties, thanks to their festive look.
- → How small should I chop nuts?
- Chop them super fine, just shy of a powder, to spread evenly.