Pin it
Mixing the warm coziness of toasted marshmallows with smooth chocolate and crunchy graham crackers takes us back to those summer nights by the fire. This frozen S'mores Explosion Cookie Dough Ice Cream Roll packs those familiar tastes into an eye-catching cold treat that'll make everyone want more. What makes it special are the different parts - a soft cookie dough wrapped around smooth vanilla ice cream, packed with all the classic s'mores stuff we can't get enough of.
When I brought this treat to our family cookout last year, it vanished in seconds. Kids were amazed by the cool swirly pattern, and grown-ups couldn't believe I made it myself. Even my super picky nephew who usually skips dessert came back for another slice.
Key Ingredients and Smart Shopping Advice:
- Whole milk and heavy cream: You need the fat they contain for that velvety ice cream feel. Don't try using low-fat stuff or you'll end up with icy patches
- Safety-treated flour: Bake it until it hits 165°F so it's safe to eat raw. This light baking also gives it a yummy toasted taste
- Mini chocolate chips: They spread better in the dough than big ones and won't mess up your rolling. Go for good quality ones that melt nicely
- Mini marshmallows: Make sure they're new - look at the date since older ones get hard and won't melt right
Simple Instructions From Start to Finish:
- Get your cookie dough ready
- Whip your room temperature butter until it's super fluffy - give it about 3 minutes. This makes your dough nice and soft
- Mix in both types of sugar bit by bit until it looks kind of like damp sand
- Add vanilla and egg just until mixed - don't overdo it or you'll end up with tough dough
- Use a spatula to gently fold in your baked flour mix, stopping once everything's combined
- Mix up your ice cream
- Stir the cream, milk, and sugar together until all the sugar melts away
- Add it to your cold ice cream maker
- Take your time churning - going too fast messes up the texture
- It's done when it looks like soft ice cream and holds a gentle peak
- Set up your workspace
- Make room in your freezer first
- Put down parchment paper bigger than your planned roll
- Flatten the cookie dough between two parchment sheets so it doesn't stick
- Keep the ice cream churning until you're totally ready
- How to roll it up
- Move fast but carefully when you spread the ice cream
- Don't forget that 1-inch space around the edges to stop overflow
- Lift the parchment slowly as you go to help with rolling
- Just patch any tears with your fingers
- Press lightly while rolling to get rid of air bubbles
Pin it
I've learned that browning the marshmallows adds such amazing flavor. My little girl always hangs around the kitchen hoping to snack on the "test bits" that don't make it into the final roll. That smell of toasty marshmallows makes me think about family camping trips and fun backyard parties.
Mastering Temperature Tricks:
How warm or cold each part is really matters in this recipe. Your cookie dough should be cool enough to work with but not so cold it breaks when you roll it. I figured this out the hard way - it works best when the dough feels like play dough.
Putting It All Together:
Making this roll is a bit like making a good sandwich - you want everything spread out evenly. I scatter the graham crumbs in three separate batches instead of all at once, so every bite has some crunch. I picked up this trick after years of making rolled desserts.
Ways to Serve It:
Let this roll be the star of your dessert table. I like to cut it up ahead of time and arrange the pieces in a circle, then pour warm chocolate sauce over everything right before serving. The mix of hot sauce and cold roll creates an amazing taste combo.
Pin it
Keeping It Fresh:
After trying lots of different ways to store this dessert, I found that wrapping it twice - once with parchment and again with plastic wrap - works best to avoid freezer burn. Taking that extra minute to wrap it properly really pays off later.
In all my time baking, this S'mores Explosion Cookie Dough Ice Cream Roll remains the thing people ask me to make most often. It mixes the comfort of childhood snacks with a fancy look that works for any party. Though it takes patience to make, seeing everyone's happy faces after their first bite makes it worth the effort. The secret is not rushing and remembering that it doesn't have to look perfect - even if the shape is a bit wonky, it'll still taste fantastic.
Fun Flavor Twists to Try:
One thing I love about this treat is how easy it is to change up. Try swapping vanilla ice cream for chocolate, peanut butter, or even coffee for a whole new taste. For an extra special touch, pour some caramel or hot fudge over the finished roll. You can also play around with different cookie doughs - chocolate chip or even brownie batter makes an amazingly rich version.
Why the Swirl Works So Well:
That pretty swirl pattern isn't just for looks - it also helps spread all the flavors and textures evenly. The trick is working quickly while your ice cream is still soft but not melty. By gently pushing the graham crumbs into the ice cream before rolling, you make a barrier that stops the ice cream from soaking into the cookie dough and making it soggy.
Getting the Marshmallows Just Right:
While tiny marshmallows spread nicely throughout, you can use big ones for more dramatic bites. If you go with larger marshmallows, try lightly toasting them under the broiler before adding them to your ice cream. This gives them that gooey, campfire taste that goes perfectly with the other s'mores parts. Just let them cool a bit before mixing them in so they don't melt your ice cream too fast.
Pin it
Making More for Big Groups:
You can easily make more of this recipe for bigger parties. Just double or triple everything, and use a bigger sheet of parchment for rolling. If you're making several rolls, you can prep the cookie dough and ice cream ahead of time and keep them separate in the fridge or freezer until you're ready to put them together. This saves tons of time and stress on party day.
Making It Look Amazing:
How this dessert looks matters almost as much as how it tastes. For a wow-worthy display, cut even slices and place them in a spiral on your serving plate. Drizzle with warm chocolate or caramel, and sprinkle extra graham bits or toasted marshmallows on top. A few berries or mint leaves add a pop of color. Your goal is a dessert that looks as good as it tastes.
From what I've seen firsthand, this S'mores Explosion Cookie Dough Ice Cream Roll is more than just a sweet treat - it's a whole experience. It takes you back to summer nights and stories around the campfire. It brings people together and creates moments you'll remember. Whether you're making it for a birthday or just because it's Friday, I really hope you'll give it a shot. You might just find your new favorite dessert.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I go with store-bought ice cream?
- Totally! Homemade is creamier, but a good store-bought one works perfectly.
- → How long does it take to freeze?
- Freeze it for no less than 4 hours, but letting it chill overnight is even better.
- → Can this dessert be prepped early?
- For sure! You can make it a week ahead. Keep it wrapped for best results.
- → What's with the mini chocolate chips?
- They’re super easy to mix in and make every bite evenly chocolaty!
- → Can I roast the marshmallows first?
- Go for it! A light toast gives them that campfire vibe. Just be sure they cool down!