Gooey Caramel Bars

These mouthwatering layered treats feature a soft cookie foundation topped with sticky caramel, chocolate chips, and a touch of peanut butter creating an unforgettable dessert that matches its daring name. The mix of textures and tastes makes an addictive snack that'll wow everyone at your next get-together. I first tried these at a local block party and had to grab the instructions after just one bite.

I remember the first batch I whipped up for my family when my teenage kid announced they were "the tastiest thing you've ever made" and secretly kept two squares for his school lunch tomorrow. There's something truly addictive about caramel mixed with chocolate.

Key Components and Smart Selection Advice

• Butter - Go with unsalted to manage the overall saltiness yourself
• Caramels - The individually wrapped soft ones work greatest; take off wrappers while your base bakes
• Chocolate Chips - Semi-sweet gives just the right taste but feel free to swap for milk or dark kinds
• Peanut Butter - Smooth type blends best in the caramel mix; pick traditional or natural based on what you like
• Evaporated Milk - This makes the caramel layer turn out perfectly smooth

The real trick happens when you pour hot caramel over the partly baked cookie layer, creating that amazing gooey middle that gets even better as it sits and cools.

Comprehensive Baking Directions

Step 1:

Set Everything Up Heat your oven to 375°F and coat a 9×13 baking dish really well. Getting all your stuff measured before you start makes everything go smoother.

Step 2:

Create Your Cookie Mix In a big bowl, combine soft butter with both types of sugar until it's fluffy and light, roughly 2-3 minutes. Pour in vanilla, then add eggs one by one, mixing well each time. In another bowl, mix flour, baking soda, and salt, then slowly add to your butter blend. Stir in chocolate chips just enough to mix them in.

Step 3:

Cook the Bottom Layer Spread half your cookie mix evenly in your greased pan. It'll be pretty thin, so try using a flat spatula or wet spoon back to help spread it out. Bake about 8-10 minutes until it firms up but isn't fully brown yet.

Step 4:

Make the Caramel Mix While your base cooks, unwrap all caramels and put them in a double boiler with evaporated milk. Melt on medium heat, stirring often so it won't burn. Once it's smooth, mix in peanut butter until it's fully blended.

Step 5:

Add Caramel to Base As soon as your cookie base comes out, pour your warm caramel mix over it, spreading to make it even. Work fast because the caramel starts hardening as it cools down.

Step 6:

Add Remaining Cookie Mix Drop spoonfuls of your leftover cookie dough on top of the caramel. Don't worry about covering every spot - the gaps let caramel show through and look pretty when baked.

Step 7:

Finish Baking Put the pan back in the oven for about 15-20 minutes until the top turns light gold. The middle might still look soft but will firm up while cooling.

Step 8:

Let Them Cool Let the whole thing cool in the pan for at least 1-2 hours before cutting. For super clean cuts, stick it in the fridge for 30 minutes after it reaches room temp.

Step 9:

Slice Into Pieces Use a sharp knife dipped in hot water and wiped between cuts for the prettiest results. Cut into 24 squares for regular sizes or smaller for bite-sized treats.

Step 10:

Serve and Keep Serve at room temp for the best gooey texture. Store in a sealed container with parchment paper between layers.

Pin it

I found out how important it is to grease your pan properly when my first batch got stuck really bad. Now I use both cooking spray and parchment with extra hanging over the sides for easy lifting out.

Fantastic Ahead-of-Time Treat

These bars get better over time as the flavors blend together. I usually make them a day before I need them for best results. For weekend parties, I'll mix them up Friday night, which gives them plenty of cooling time. The texture sets perfectly overnight and the caramel layer gets an even richer taste. This makes them great for busy people who want awesome desserts without last-minute rushing around.

Gift-Giving and Display Suggestions

When giving these as holiday gifts, I cut them into smaller squares and pack them in pretty tins with parchment lining. I put waxed paper between layers so they won't stick together. With a nice ribbon and handwritten note, they become fancy homemade presents that friends ask for every year. At bake sales, I wrap them individually in parchment and stack them on a wooden board to catch everyone's eye.

Pin it

Tasty Holiday Tweaks

I like to change these up for different celebrations throughout the year. For Valentine's Day, I sprinkle a bit of pink sea salt on the caramel part. Summer birthday versions get a thin drizzle of white chocolate on top after cooling. During Christmas, I mix in crushed candy canes into the top cookie layer. Fall gatherings call for a touch of cinnamon and tiny bit of nutmeg in the cookie mix for that warm seasonal flavor.

Kid-Friendly Changes

When making these for events with kids around, I sometimes swap out peanut butter for cookie butter to avoid allergy issues. Using mini chocolate chips creates a smoother texture that picky eaters prefer. I've also set up a "decorate your own bar" station with things like sprinkles, tiny marshmallows, or crushed cookies so kids can customize their treats, turning dessert into a fun activity everyone gets into.

Pro Baker Advice

• Put parchment paper in your pan with extra hanging over for easy lifting
• Slightly undercook the bottom layer for a perfectly chewy result
• Add a cup of chopped pecans to the cookie mix for extra richness
• Always melt caramel using a double boiler to avoid burning
• Chill in the fridge for 30 minutes before cutting for clean edges

I've fine-tuned these tips after many batches, especially after learning that using a double boiler makes way smoother caramel than cooking directly on the stove.

These awesome bars have become my go-to contribution for potlucks and family events. There's just something about how the different textures work together - that slight crunch on the outside giving way to gooey caramel and melted chocolate inside - that makes everyone come back for seconds.

Pin it

Closing Suggestions

• For a fancier flavor, mix a teaspoon of espresso powder into the cookie dough
• Make a pretty pattern by swirling the caramel with a knife before adding the top layer
• Try mixing up your chips with butterscotch or white chocolate instead
• Use a plastic knife to cut chilled bars for surprisingly clean slices
• Let bars warm up to room temperature before eating for the best texture

These incredible treats show that sometimes the most impressive sweets don't need fancy techniques or hard-to-find ingredients - just the right combo of flavors and textures layered together with a little love.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I swap melted caramels with caramel sauce?

Caramel sauce is often thinner, so it might not thicken as much. For best results, go with unwrapped caramels.

→ When do I know these bars are ready?

Look for a light gold color on top, and the edges will pull just a bit away from the pan.

→ Can these be frozen?

Definitely! After cooling, slice into squares and keep them in a sealed container with parchment in between for up to three months.

→ Can I use something besides peanut butter?

Sure thing! Almond butter or cookie butter could bring fun new flavors.

→ What's with the name 'Knock You Naked' bars?

Folks say the taste is so incredible, they'll knock your socks (and more) off!