Pin it
Stuffed peppers take on a whole new life with this seafood twist, where colorful bell peppers hold a rich mixture of crab and shrimp. This fancy dish brings together seaside tastes with melty cheese and fragrant herbs.
While trying out this dish, I noticed that cooking the peppers just shy of done keeps them sturdy and the filling stays juicy.
Key Ingredients and Smart Shopping Advice
- Bell Peppers - Pick sturdy, symmetrical ones that can stand up by themselves
- Crab Meat - Go for lump or jumbo lump for the nicest chunks and look
- Shrimp - Medium ones cut into small chunks mix in best
- Cream Cheese - Regular, not light, melts better and tastes richer
Step-by-Step Cooking Guide
- 1. Getting Peppers Ready
- Make tiny cuts on pepper bottoms so they stand up. Cook them for 5 minutes first if you want them softer.
- 2. Working With Seafood
- Mix seafood into cheese mix carefully to keep chunks whole. Make sure it's well-drained to avoid soggy filling.
- 3. Mixing The Filling
- Whip cream cheese until it's fluffy before you add other stuff. Add seasonings bit by bit for better taste.
- 4. Baking Just Right
- Watch carefully during final heating - cheese should get golden not black. Wait 5 minutes before eating.
- 5. Getting Temps Right
- Let cream cheese warm up before mixing. Don't cook seafood too long in the oven.
Pin it
My grandma always told me the secret to amazing stuffed peppers is timing everything so both the pepper and what's inside finish cooking at the same moment.
What's great about this dish is how it works for anything - fancy enough for special dinners but easy enough for a regular weeknight meal.
Tasty Twists and Add-ins
Try throwing in some capers, chopped olives, or roasted red peppers for an Italian feel. Add diced celery or water chestnuts if you want some crunch. Play around with different cheeses - fontina and gruyere taste amazing too. For really special times, put some buttery lobster pieces on top before serving.
Pin it
Party Ideas and Serving Suggestions
These fancy peppers look amazing at dinner parties. Set them on a big plate with fresh herbs, lemon slices, and edible flowers. Make a seafood spread by serving them with crab cakes and shrimp cocktail. Use red, yellow and green peppers to make your table pop.
Getting Temps and Timing Just Right
The right temperature makes all the difference. Take cream cheese out 30 minutes early so it softens. Let peppers sit for 5-7 minutes after cooking so filling sets up. If making ahead, let assembled peppers warm up before baking.
Making It Healthier
Add more good stuff by mixing in quinoa, farro, or riced cauliflower. Toss in spinach or kale for extra vitamins. Try reduced-fat cream cheese and cut back on cheese if you want. Bulk it up with extra veggies like mushrooms or zucchini.
Other Ways To Cook Them
Try them on the grill for a smoky taste. Use your air fryer at the 370°F setting for 12-15 minutes when you're in a hurry. Steam the peppers briefly first if you want them softer. For big groups, cook them in a slow cooker on low for 4-6 hours.
Pin it
To wrap up: These stuffed peppers show how seafood and veggies can come together for an amazing meal. The sweet peppers filled with rich seafood create perfect flavor balance, great for both family dinners and special get-togethers.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I prepare these in advance?
- Absolutely! Put them together up to a day before and refrigerate. Just bake a bit longer—an extra 5-10 minutes straight from the fridge.
- → Which crab meat works best?
- Lump crab meat is ideal for the best taste and texture. Claw meat is a great budget option though.
- → Are they freezer-friendly?
- Yes! Freeze before baking. Let them thaw in the fridge overnight and extend baking time by 10-15 minutes.
- → What should I serve with them?
- Try a fresh green salad or roasted veggies. They're hearty enough to enjoy on their own if you prefer.
- → Can I replace crab with imitation crab?
- You can, but real crab's flavor and texture are much better. If you use imitation, just bump up the seasoning a bit.