Pin it
From my kitchen experiments comes this incredible twist on grilled cheese that tastes just like pizza. I spread garlicky Parmesan butter on the bread, then stuff it with gooey mozzarella and pepperoni. A warm bowl of pizza sauce on the side makes it perfect for dipping.
Pizza Plus Grilled Cheese Makes Magic
Late one night I couldn't choose between pizza or grilled cheese, so I threw them together and oh my goodness! The combination is unreal. Picture hot crusty bread filled with stretchy mozzarella and spicy pepperoni. My kids go crazy for these now they won't even ask for regular pizza anymore.
What Makes This So Good
You can whip these up so fast when hunger strikes. The best part is making them your own with your favorite pizza toppings. Even my picky nephew demolished his slice. It's seriously the best of both worlds in one melty sandwich.
Grab These From Your Kitchen
- Fresh Butter: Gets that outside golden and crunchy
- Good Cheese: Lots of mozzarella plus some Parmesan
- Pizza Goodies: Pepperoni slices and marinara for dipping
- Nice Bread: Something that can hold up to all the cheese
- Extra Yum: Garlic powder and Italian herbs make it special
Let's Make It
Start with the Butter: Mix soft butter with Parm cheese, garlic powder and Italian herbs this makes it amazing.
Stack it Up: Spread that tasty butter on your bread. Layer mozzarella, pepperoni, then more cheese because cheese is life.
Cook it Slow: Keep the heat not too high so everything gets melty before burning. Press down a little with your spatula.
Careful Flip: Once it's golden underneath, flip gently. Watch close cause the second side goes fast.
Time to Dive In: Cut in half and watch that cheese stretch! Dip in hot pizza sauce and enjoy.
Pin it
My Secret Tips
Take your time cooking no rushing here. Want extra crunch? Throw some Parmesan right on the outside butter. Using fresh mozzarella? Dry it off first or your sandwich gets wet. And please don't forget extra sauce for dipping.
How to Enjoy It
You gotta eat this while it's super hot that's when the cheese is at its stretchiest! Got some left? Heat it back up in a pan never microwave or it gets soggy. Want to feel less guilty? Throw a little salad next to it.
Fun Ways to Switch It Up
Toss in some fresh spinach if you're feeling fancy. Take your time cooking just like they do in fancy restaurants. And seriously, grate your own cheese it melts so much better than the pre-shredded stuff.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why use medium-low heat for cooking?
- Lower heat lets the cheese melt completely without burning the butter. The bread gets golden brown while the inside gets hot and gooey.
- → Can I use different cheese instead of mozzarella?
- While mozzarella gives that pizza flavor, provolone or white American cheese work well too. They both melt nicely and taste great with pepperoni.
- → How do I keep the layers from falling apart?
- Press down gently on the sandwich while cooking and flip carefully with a wide spatula. The melted cheese helps hold everything together.
- → Can I add other pizza toppings?
- Try adding thin slices of mushrooms, onions, or bell peppers. Just make sure they're sliced very thin so the sandwich cooks evenly.
- → Why spread butter to the edges?
- Buttering right to the edges ensures even browning and helps prevent dry spots. It also gives that perfect crispy crust all around.