Pin it
This mouthwatering Irish cream mega cookie creation elevates basic chocolate chip treats with the luscious taste of Baileys. When you mix multiple chocolate types with crunchy toffee bits, you get an amazing blend of texture and flavor that makes these cookies absolutely addictive for parties or weekend baking fun.
I whipped these up for a St. Patrick's Day gathering and everyone went crazy for them. They've now turned into my go-to dessert that my buddies specifically ask for when they come over. That Bailey's topping adds just the right touch that gets people begging for my secret recipe.
What You'll Need
- Chilled butter: this is key for getting that perfect consistency and stopping cookies from flattening too much
- White and brown sugar: this mix gives you that awesome chewy middle with crispy edges
- Irish cream liqueur: brings smooth vanilla and caramel hints without being too strong
- Espresso powder: makes chocolate taste even better without adding coffee flavor
- Cornstarch: the hidden trick for super soft cookies with a lovely tender bite
- Several chocolate types: using different kinds creates interesting spots of varying sweetness
- Broken chocolate sandwich cookies: adds surprise crunch and boosts the chocolate intensity
- Toffee pieces: bring caramel notes that work wonderfully with the Irish cream
Making Your Cookies
- Mix Your Base:
- Beat cold butter chunks with both sugars for only 1-2 minutes until just combined. Many recipes tell you to use room temp butter but cold butter is what gives you that awesome texture. Don't mix too long or your cookies will spread way too much.
- Add Depth Of Taste:
- Put eggs in one at a time, making sure each one's fully mixed before adding another. Then stir in the Irish cream, vanilla, and almond extracts. This combo creates rich flavor that makes these cookies stand out. The liqueur brings buttery caramel notes that really work with the chocolate.
- Get The Right Texture:
- Mix dry stuff separately before slowly adding it to wet ingredients. Stir just until you can't see flour anymore. Too much mixing makes cookies tough instead of soft. The cornstarch is your hidden weapon for cookies that melt in your mouth.
- Add The Good Stuff:
- Carefully fold in all your mix-ins with a wooden spoon instead of your mixer. This keeps the chocolate and cookie bits from breaking up. The different textures make these cookies special – every bite gives you something new.
- Shape Them Right:
- Make big 5-6 ounce balls of dough, keeping them tall not flat. This huge size gives them that impressive bakery look. The tall shape means they'll bake with slightly crunchy edges and perfectly gooey middles.
- Smart Baking Method:
- Cook at a higher temp (410°F) for less time to get that perfect texture contrast. The high heat quickly firms up the edges while keeping the middle soft and rich. Always chill unused dough between batches to keep that cold butter advantage.
- Cool Properly:
- Let cookies sit on the baking sheet for a full 30 minutes before moving to a cooling rack. This step is super important for texture as they keep cooking from leftover heat. The centers will sink slightly, creating that perfect dense chewy middle.
- Add The Topping:
- Drizzle completely cooled cookies with Irish cream icing using a spoon or piping bag. The slightly boozy sweet topping enhances the flavor and looks amazing. Let the icing harden completely overnight for the best experience.
Pin it
I stumbled on using espresso powder by chance when I ran out of vanilla once and grabbed it by mistake. The change was so amazing that I now put it in all my chocolate recipes to boost the chocolate flavor without making anything taste like coffee.
Keeping Them Fresh
These big cookies stay good at room temp in a sealed container for about 5 days. For the tastiest results, I suggest warming them in the microwave for 10 seconds before eating after day one. This brings back those melty chocolate pockets and makes them taste fresh from the oven. If you want to keep them longer, wrap each cookie in plastic and put them in a freezer bag where they'll stay good for up to 3 months. Let them thaw at room temp for 2 hours before enjoying.
Pin it
Creating That Amazing Irish Cream Topping
The Bailey's drizzle turns these cookies from great to mind-blowing. Getting the right thickness is crucial - it should be runny enough to drizzle prettily but thick enough to set well and not soak into the cookies. Start with less liquid and slowly add more until you get a mix that holds its shape for a few seconds when lifted with a spoon before melting back down. For stronger Irish cream flavor, swap the vanilla in the drizzle with a bit more Baileys. Let the topped cookies sit uncovered for at least 2 hours before packing them away to keep the icing from getting sticky.
Smart Swaps
While Baileys stars in this recipe, you can try other flavored liqueurs to create totally different cookie experiences. Give Kahlúa a go for coffee vibes, Frangelico for nutty notes, or Amaretto to highlight the almond extract. For a booze-free version, use Irish cream coffee creamer or make your own by mixing 2 tablespoons heavy cream with 1 teaspoon vanilla and 1/4 teaspoon almond extract. You can replace the crushed cookies with graham cracker bits, broken Oreos, or even crushed pretzels for a sweet-salty combo that works beautifully with the Irish cream sweetness.
Ways To Serve Them
These giant cookies become an awesome dessert when slightly warmed and topped with vanilla ice cream. The mix of warm cookie and cold ice cream creates an amazing contrast that makes the experience even better. For something super fancy, use them as the base for an Irish coffee sundae with coffee ice cream, whipped cream, and chocolate sauce drizzled on top. They also go great with a glass of milk for kids, or for grown-ups, a small glass of Irish whiskey or a cup of Irish coffee that brings out the cookie's flavors.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why are these flavors similar to King Cake?
They combine cinnamon, nutmeg, almond, and cream cheese, mirroring the classic King Cake flavor profile. The bright sanding sugar ties in the traditional Mardi Gras colors.
- → What makes Levain-style cookies special?
These cookies stand out for their crunchy outside, soft gooey center, and extra-thick size, giving your kitchen that bakery feel.
- → Can I substitute regular cream cheese?
Chunks or chips work better to keep the right texture, but soft cream cheese mixed right into the dough can still get the job done.
- → How do I keep them nice and thick?
Chill your dough before you bake it and shape it into tall mounds. That way, the cookies stay thick and have those lovely soft middles.
- → What’s the best way to store them?
Put them in an airtight container to keep at room temperature for up to three days, or tuck them in the fridge for a week. Warm them up a bit when you’re ready to enjoy!