Pin it
When creamy, cheesy pasta meets crunchy chicken coated in sweet-hot honey pepper glaze, you get a mind-blowing comfort food mashup. From the crisp exterior of the chicken to the velvety cheese coating the pasta, every part works together to make this Applebee's knockoff that'll quickly become a regular request at your dinner table.
I've found that letting the honey pepper mixture bubble away for the whole 15 minutes really makes all the difference in getting that sticky, restaurant-quality consistency. Last month, my kids actually asked for this instead of going out for their birthday celebration - that's when I knew my homemade version was spot on!
Key Components and Buying Advice
- Pasta: Go for spiral cavatappi or curved elbows that trap sauce in their grooves. New pasta works wonderfully, though dried varieties stay firmer in leftovers
- Cheese Combo: Skip pre-shredded bags and grate your own for the creamiest results. Mixing sharp cheddar, stretchy mozzarella, and nutty Parmesan creates amazing flavor layers
- Chicken: Cut pieces to similar sizes so they cook evenly. When buying prepared options, pick plain strips - they soak up the honey pepper sauce better
- Heavy Cream: Don't skimp here - only full-fat cream creates that silky-smooth sauce. Lighter options like milk won't work
Step-by-Step Cooking Guide
- 1. Getting Chicken Just Right
- Dust chicken strips with salt and pepper. Warm oil to 350°F in your biggest skillet. Fry strips about 4-5 minutes each side until golden and cooked through (165°F inside). Place on a wire rack - this clever trick keeps them crispy all around.
- 2. Whipping Up Honey Pepper Glaze
- Mix all sauce stuff in a pot over medium flame. Keep an eye on it as it starts bubbling - honey can quickly bubble over! Turn heat down fast and keep it just barely simmering. Give it a stir every couple minutes so nothing sticks. It's done when it coats your spoon nicely.
- 3. Getting Pasta Right
- Boil pasta in very salty water until just firm to the bite. Save a cup of the starchy water before draining. Don't wash the pasta - that starch helps sauce stick! Toss with a tiny bit of oil in the pot so it won't clump together.
- 4. Creating Cheese Magic
- Melt butter with cream on low heat - rushing causes separation. Add cheese bit by bit, stirring non-stop. If it gets too thick, splash in some saved pasta water a spoonful at a time. Look for a smooth, flowing texture without graininess.
- 5. Putting It All Together
- Mix bacon pieces right into the cheese sauce, then add pasta. Dunk each chicken piece in the honey pepper mixture, letting extra drip off. Set up pasta in bowls, place glazed chicken on top, then sprinkle with fresh basil and a crack of pepper.
Pin it
Our family's little trick is adding just a tiny bit of nutmeg to the cheese sauce - you can't taste it directly but it somehow makes the cheese flavor pop. I tried tons of versions and this small touch really made everything come together.
Watching Your Heat
Getting temperatures right changes everything in this dish. Start with furiously boiling water for pasta, keep oil steady at 350°F for crispy chicken, and never let cheese sauce get hotter than a gentle simmer. Give chicken a 5-minute rest before adding sauce or it'll slide right off. Watch that honey pepper mixture like a hawk while it cooks down - the temperature makes or breaks its thickness.
Pin it
Setting Up Your Ingredients
Getting everything ready first saves you trouble. Grate cheese while waiting for water to boil, cook bacon ahead, and measure out honey pepper sauce ingredients. This planning stops cheese sauce from breaking and keeps pasta from turning mushy. Pour measured liquids into easy-to-handle cups for smooth sauce making.
Do-Ahead Options
Make parts separately for quicker dinner assembly. Cook bacon and honey pepper sauce up to three days before. Cheese sauce warms up nicely with a splash of cream. Cook pasta slightly firm if you'll reheat it later. Store chicken uncovered in the fridge to keep it crunchy.
How to Serve It
Bring it to the table on one big platter or in individual bowls. Top with torn basil leaves, extra bacon bits, and a little warm honey pepper sauce. Serve right away while everything's hot and the cheese sauce flows. Keep some extra sauce warm for anyone who wants more.
Dealing With Leftovers
Keep pasta with cheese sauce apart from chicken when storing. Warm up pasta mix over low heat with a bit of cream. Crisp up chicken again in a 350°F oven for 5-7 minutes. Better yet, mix up fresh honey pepper sauce since stored sauce gets too thick.
Pin it
Wrapping Up
This fancy mac and cheese turns a popular restaurant item into something even better at home. The mix of perfectly cooked pasta, rich cheese coating, crunchy chicken pieces, and that amazing honey pepper glaze creates something both familiar and special. The secret to nailing it is taking your time with each part and keeping a close eye on temperatures throughout.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I use store-bought shredded cheese?
- It's better to shred your own since pre-shredded cheese has additives that mess with the texture.
- → Can I prep this in advance?
- You can make the sauces early, but mix everything fresh. The cheese could break when reheating.
- → Is it spicy?
- There's just a touch of heat from cayenne. Feel free to tweak it.
- → Can I swap the pasta type?
- Sure, any medium pasta will do. Shapes like spirals cling to sauce nicely.
- → What else works instead of pineapple juice?
- Apple or orange juice can be used, though the flavor will be a little different.