Pin it
This dreamy Boston Cream Pie brings together three perfect parts - soft vanilla sponge, smooth custard filling, and dark chocolate topping. Every bite shows off the beautiful layers that honor its roots at the historic Parker House Hotel while giving you that perfect mix of tastes and textures.
Whipping up this treat links me to bakers from the past. When I finally got all three parts right, I remembered my grandma saying: "Take your time for the best custard filling." These days it's my favorite cake for any celebration.
Key Components
- Unsalted Butter: Softened completely
- Large Eggs: Taken out ahead of time
- Whole Milk: Needed for both parts
- All-Purpose Flour: Measured carefully
- Pure Vanilla Bean: Both inside and the shell
- Bittersweet Chocolate (70%): For the top layer
- Heavy Cream: Makes smooth topping
- Fresh Baking Powder: Helps it puff up
- Kosher Salt: Brings out sweetness
MAKING IT STEP BY STEP
- 1. Begin With Custard:
- Start the custard first since it needs cooling time. Warm milk with vanilla bean pieces until hot but not boiling. In another bowl, mix egg yolks, sugar, and cornstarch until light yellow. Slowly pour hot milk into egg mix, stirring constantly, then pour everything back into the pot and cook until it thickens enough to coat a spoon.
- 2. Prepare The Cake:
- Beat butter and sugar together until fluffy and pale, about 3-4 minutes. Drop in eggs one by one, mixing well each time. Add vanilla. Switch between adding dry stuff and milk, starting and finishing with the flour mixture. Don't mix too much.
- 3. Baking The Layers:
- Put equal amounts of batter into two greased 9-inch pans. Bake at 350°F for 22-25 minutes until a stick comes out clean and the top bounces back when touched. Let cool in pans for 15 minutes before flipping onto cooling racks.
- 4. Making The Topping:
- Heat cream just until tiny bubbles form at the edge. Pour it over chopped chocolate chunks, wait 5 minutes, then stir until smooth and shiny. Add a tiny bit of corn syrup for extra shine if you want.
- 5. Putting It All Together:
- Cut each cake round in half sideways. Spread custard between cake layers. Pour chocolate mixture on top, letting it flow down the sides naturally.
Pin it
The pastry expert who taught me always said good Boston Cream Pie comes down to patience and the right temperatures. "You can't hurry greatness," she would remind me, and this dessert really proves her point.
Keeping It Fresh
Keep your finished cake in the fridge, under a dome or wrapped loosely, for up to 3 days. You can also prep parts ahead: custard stays good refrigerated for 2 days, cake layers wrapped tightly will freeze for a month, and the chocolate topping keeps in the fridge for a week (just warm it gently). For the best taste, let the cake sit out about 30 minutes before you serve it.
Serving Suggestions
Though typically enjoyed cold, this dessert tastes even better when it warms up slightly. This softens the custard and makes the chocolate topping extra silky. For fancy occasions, add a spoonful of whipped cream or scatter fresh berries alongside. In hot weather, try putting individual pieces in the fridge briefly before serving for a cooler treat.
Pin it
Tasty Twists
Switch up this classic by playing with flavors - mix coffee powder into the chocolate for a coffee kick, or add orange zest to the custard. For a fancy look, top with chocolate shavings, candied orange peel, or edible flowers. The basic recipe welcomes little changes while keeping its traditional charm. Just like the chefs at Parker House Hotel figured out, sometimes the simplest combinations make the most unforgettable desserts.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I prepare any parts ahead?
- Sure, the cream can be ready up to 3 days ahead. Assemble the cake the day before serving.
- → Why do I need to strain the cream?
- It gets rid of clumps or bits of cooked egg, leaving the cream silky smooth.
- → Can this dessert be frozen?
- Freezing will change the cream's texture, so it's not a great idea.
- → Why’s it called a pie when it’s not?
- Back in the day, this was cooked in pie tins, so the name stuck.
- → Can I swap vanilla paste for extract?
- Yep, just double the quantity if you're using extract.