Pin it
This indulgent Lobster, Crab, and Shrimp Macaroni and Cheese takes everyday comfort food to new heights. Mixing three delicious seafoods with a smooth, rich cheese sauce creates a meal that's both familiar and fancy at the same time.
I first whipped this up for a stay-at-home anniversary dinner, and now we can't celebrate without it. Even my friends who aren't big seafood fans beg me for this recipe after they've had just one taste at our get-togethers.
Ingredients
- Elbow macaroni: Makes up the filling base and catches all that yummy sauce in its little curves
- Shrimp: Brings a light sweetness and nice chewy bite
- Lobster tails: Give that amazing buttery sweetness that makes this dish stand out
- Crab meat: Adds a soft texture and gentle sea flavor
- Sharp cheddar cheese: Brings that must-have mac and cheese taste
- Monterey Jack: Creates those perfect stringy cheese pulls with its mild flavor
- Gouda: Adds a hint of smokiness that works great with seafood
- Gruyere: Brings nutty flavors and melts beautifully
- Half and half and evaporated milk: Make everything creamy without being too much
- Panko breadcrumbs: Give you that needed crunchy top against all the creaminess below
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Prepare the Seafood:
- First, melt butter in a big pot over medium low heat. Toss in your diced onions and let them cook until they're see-through and smell good, about 4 minutes. This creates your flavor base. Toss in minced garlic and keep stirring for exactly a minute so it releases flavor without burning. Now add your raw shrimp and watch them turn from gray to pretty pink, around 5 minutes. Don't forget to flip them halfway. Once they're pink, carefully mix in your already cooked lobster and crab, just warming them through without breaking the pieces. Sprinkle your spice mix over everything, gently mixing to cover all the seafood. It should smell amazing but not too strong. Move all this to a bowl, making sure to scrape up all the tasty bits from the pot.
- Make the Cheese Sauce:
- Use that same pot to keep all those seafood flavors. Melt your leftover butter over medium heat. Sprinkle flour while constantly whisking to make a light roux, cooking just one minute to get rid of that raw flour taste. Slowly pour in the barely warm milk in a steady stream while whisking like crazy to avoid lumps. Keep whisking as you add chicken broth, half and half, and evaporated milk. Let everything come to a gentle bubble, then turn down the heat. Start adding your cheese mix one small handful at a time, stirring between each addition until it's completely melted. This slow approach keeps your sauce smooth and creamy. When done, the sauce should stick nicely to a spoon and look silky.
- Cook the Pasta:
- While working on your sauce, cook the macaroni in really salty water for two minutes less than what the box says. You want it a bit firm since it'll cook more in the oven. Drain it well, then mix with olive oil so it doesn't stick together.
- Combine and Bake:
- Carefully stir your slightly firm pasta into the cheese sauce until every piece is coated. Next, mix in your seafood, spreading it evenly throughout. Pour everything into your baking dish and smooth the top. Sprinkle the remaining cheeses over it, followed by a layer of panko for crunchiness. Cover with foil and bake at 350°F for 25 minutes, then uncover for the last 10 minutes to get that golden crispy top.
Pin it
I really love the lobster in this dish. My grandma got me hooked on lobster mac and cheese during our Maine summer visits, and this version grew from her basic recipe. Whenever I cook it, I think about those special times with her, carefully picking meat from lobster shells while she worked on her famous cheese sauce.
Make Ahead Strategy
This seafood mac and cheese works great for parties because you can do it in steps. You can cook and season the seafood a day early and keep it in the fridge. You can also cook the pasta ahead, mix it with olive oil, and refrigerate. When it's time to eat, just make the cheese sauce, mix everything together, and bake. This makes the whole process less scary and lets you hang out with your guests instead of rushing around the kitchen.
Pin it
Balancing Flavors
What makes this recipe work so well is how it balances rich and tangy flavors. The creamy cheese sauce and buttery seafood need something to cut through all that richness. A dash of Tabasco adds brightness without making things spicy, while well-salted pasta water brings out all the flavors. For even more depth, try adding a spoonful of Dijon mustard to your cheese sauce or sprinkling fresh lemon zest on top after baking. These little touches cut through the richness and make the seafood taste even better.
Serving Suggestions
You can make this mac and cheese feel casual or fancy depending on how you serve it. For a nice dinner, bake it in separate small dishes. Serve it with something bright and tangy like lemon roasted asparagus or a simple arugula salad with champagne dressing. A cold bottle of Chardonnay or Sauvignon Blanc goes perfectly with it. For a more relaxed meal, just bring the whole bubbly dish to the table with some crusty bread for soaking up all that amazing sauce.
Seafood Selection Guide
The seafood quality really makes or breaks this dish. For lobster, fresh tails taste best, but frozen ones work fine if you thaw them in the fridge overnight. When buying shrimp, look for firm ones that smell mildly like the ocean, not fishy. Wild caught American shrimp usually taste better than imported kinds. For crab, lump meat gives you nice big chunks, while claw meat has a stronger flavor. Don't use fake crab, as its strange sweetness and texture will ruin the fancy feel of your dish.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I swap the seafood for other options?
Absolutely! Mussels, scallops, or even canned crab are excellent swaps. Just be mindful of adjusting cooking times.
- → What are good cheese substitutes for this recipe?
If you can’t find Gruyere or Gouda, Havarti or Fontina work well. They all melt beautifully!
- → How do I make it spicier?
Crank up the heat with some extra cayenne, crushed red pepper flakes, Cajun seasoning, or a bit of Tabasco sauce.
- → Can I prepare it a day in advance?
You sure can. Assemble everything, pop it in the fridge, and bake it fresh when you're ready to eat.
- → What’s the best way to reheat it?
An oven set to 325°F is best to bring it back to life. If using the microwave, stir in a splash of milk to keep it creamy.